Skip to main contentSkip to main content
10 Federal Storage logo

STORE OR REPLACE CALCULATOR

Keep It or Let It Go?

Some things are worth paying to store. Some aren't. Enter what you're storing, what it would cost to replace, and how long you'll need the space. We'll sort your list honestly, even when the honest answer is to sell it.

  • Your numbersEvery figure comes from you
  • Item by itemA verdict and break-even point for each
  • HonestIncluding when storage isn't the answer

Your Storage Plan

Use the numbers from your own quote. We don't fill in a monthly cost for you, because pricing varies by facility and unit.

What You're Storing

Price each item at what you'd actually pay to replace it today, new or used. Leave vehicles off this list.

Your Results

Add a few items and a monthly cost, and your sorted list shows up here.

Item sizes are moving-industry estimates. The calculator assumes about 70 percent of a unit's space holds belongings. Results are a guide for your decision, not a quote.

How the Calculator Decides

The calculator compares two numbers for every item: what it costs to keep it in storage, and what you'd lose by letting it go.

The cost of keeping is the item's share of your monthly cost, based on how much of the unit it fills, multiplied by the months you plan to store. It also picks up its share of any one-time costs, like a truck or moving help. A sofa that fills a tenth of your unit carries a tenth of the rent. Item sizes come from common moving-industry volume estimates, and the calculator assumes about 70 percent of a unit's space holds belongings once you leave room for an aisle and the gaps between pieces.

The value of keeping is what replacing the item would realistically cost, weighted by how likely you are to need it again, minus whatever you could sell it for today. If there's only an even chance you'll want that treadmill back, the calculator counts half its replacement cost. And if you could sell something now, that cash is part of the case for letting go.

When keeping costs clearly less than the value, the item is a Keep. When it costs clearly more, it's a Let go. Anything within 20 percent either way is a Close call. Items you mark as irreplaceable get Your call, because money can't settle those.

Each Keep, Let go, and Close call item also gets a break-even point: the month its storage cost catches up with its value. That's the number to watch if your plans could run longer than expected. The bar under each item shows it at a glance: the solid stretch is how long the item is worth storing, the striped stretch is where it costs more than it's worth, and the red mark is the end of your plan.

Letting Go Saves Money Only When Your Unit Gets Smaller

Here's the part most storage companies leave out. Your rent is set by the unit, not by what's inside it. Letting go of a floor lamp and three boxes won't change your bill if everything else still needs the same size unit.

The savings come in steps. When the things worth keeping fit in a smaller unit, or when nothing on the list is worth keeping at all, your monthly cost actually drops. That's why the calculator adds up the space your Keep and Your call items need and shows the smallest unit that holds them. If that unit is smaller than the one you planned on, that's the move with real money attached.

If your keep list still needs the same unit, the let-go items could ride along in the leftover space at no extra rent. The math still says they aren't worth keeping, and selling them now turns them into cash while they're worth something. But you won't pay more to store a lamp in space you're already renting. That one is up to you.

Want to double-check the size?

The storage size calculator sizes a unit room by room, and the storage unit layout planner shows how your keep list would sit inside it.

What Is Usually Worth Storing

The pattern is value for its size. A small thing that's expensive or impossible to replace costs very little to store, because it takes up so little of the unit. These usually clear the bar:

  • Anything you'll need back soon. A few months between homes, a renovation, or a deployment is where storage makes the most sense, because a short stay costs little next to refurnishing.
  • Solid, well-made furniture. A solid wood dresser or dining set often costs far more to replace than its share of a unit, and it holds up to being moved and stored.
  • Tools and equipment. Dense, valuable for their size, and tedious to rebuy piece by piece.
  • Heirlooms and keepsakes. Irreplaceable by definition. The calculator leaves these to you.
  • Things that are hard to find again. Discontinued pieces, unusual sizes, or a sectional that fits one particular room.
  • Children's furniture with a next user. A crib or bunk beds for a younger sibling, or a desk that will be needed again in a couple of years.

What Usually Isn't Worth Storing

The reverse pattern: big, inexpensive, and easy to buy again. Stored for a long stretch, these can cost more than their replacement.

  • Inexpensive flat-pack furniture. It takes real space, it's cheap to replace, and it often doesn't survive being taken apart and put back together.
  • Mattresses near the end of their life. A worn mattress takes up as much room as a dresser and is due for replacement anyway.
  • Older large appliances. They're bulky, an aging appliance may be close to replacement, and your next home may come with its own.
  • Duplicates. The second set of dishes, the extra coffee table, the spare everything from combining two households.
  • Electronics that lose value quickly. An older TV or computer is worth less every month it sits.
  • Outgrown things kept just in case. Clothes, sports gear, and hobby supplies nobody has touched in years.

None of this means you can't store these things. It means you should run the numbers first. Sometimes a big, cheap item is still a Keep because you'll only need it stored for two months.

When Storing Wins Even If the Math Is Close

The calculator counts dollars. A few things it can't count can tip a Close call, or even a mild Let go, toward storage:

  • Your time. Selling and rebuying is work: listings, messages, pickups, shopping, waiting for new furniture to arrive, and assembly. For a short stay, that work often isn't worth the savings.
  • You're not ready to decide. After a loss, a divorce, or a move you aren't sure will stick, storage buys time. Every 10 Federal rental is month-to-month, so you're never locked in. Pick a date to revisit the unit, then rerun this calculator with your real numbers.
  • Thin resale markets. If a piece would be hard to sell, the "could sell it for" figure may be optimistic.
  • A replacement wouldn't be the same. Some things are technically replaceable but you'd never find the same one. That's worth marking as irreplaceable.

What to Do With the Let-Go Pile

Letting go works best with a plan and a deadline, so the pile doesn't end up in storage by default.

  • Sell the valuable pieces first. Local marketplace apps and consignment shops work well for furniture. A yard sale clears lots of small things at once. Give each listing a deadline, then donate what hasn't sold.
  • Offer things to family and friends. Someone may want the dining set, and it stays in the family without costing you rent.
  • Donate. Many charities pick up furniture. Call ahead, since some don't accept mattresses or large appliances.
  • Recycle or haul away the rest. Many cities offer bulk pickup, and appliance retailers and utilities often run recycling programs.
  • Photograph the sentimental things you let go. A photo keeps the memory without the square footage.

Storing What You Keep for the Long Haul

If the calculator says keep, set things up so they come out the way they went in.

  • Clean everything first. Stored dirt and crumbs don't improve with time.
  • Take apart what comes apart. Bed frames, table legs, and shelving take far less room broken down. Bag and label the hardware and tape it to the piece it belongs to.
  • Cover furniture with moving blankets or cloth covers, and keep heavy items off upholstered pieces.
  • Put what you'll need first near the door, and leave an aisle so you can reach the back without unloading the front.
  • Check temperature needs. If you're unsure whether something needs a climate-controlled unit, the climate control decision tool will tell you, and it often says you don't.

Every move-in includes a free lock, and nearly every facility has 24/7 gate access, so you can check on things or pull something out whenever you need to. For more, see our storage tips.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to store furniture or buy new?

It depends on three things: how long you'll store it, how much space it takes, and what replacing it would really cost. Short stays favor storage for most furniture. Long stays favor letting go of large, inexpensive pieces. Small, valuable, or irreplaceable things are often worth storing for years. The calculator on this page runs the math item by item with your own numbers.

How long is it worth keeping furniture in storage?

Every item has a break-even point: the month when its storage cost catches up with what it would cost to replace. For a large, inexpensive piece, that can come quickly. For a solid wood dresser or a set of good tools, it can be years away. Add your items to the calculator and it shows the break-even point for each one.

Does getting rid of some items lower my storage cost?

Only if it lets you rent a smaller unit or skip storage entirely. Rent is set by the unit, not by what's inside it, so letting go of a few small things won't change your bill. The calculator adds up the space your keep items need and shows the smallest unit that holds them.

What monthly cost should I enter?

Enter the full monthly cost from your quote: the rent plus the protection plan, which is required at checkout at every 10 Federal facility, and any other recurring charges on the quote. Leases are month-to-month, so there's no long-term contract to spread out.

How do I estimate replacement cost?

Price what you would actually buy, today. Look up current listings for the same or a comparable item, new or used depending on how you'd really shop. Don't use what you originally paid, and don't price a nicer version than you'd buy.

Why does the calculator ask whether I'll use something again?

Because a thing you'll probably never use again isn't worth its full replacement cost to you. The calculator counts the full replacement cost for Definitely, three quarters for Probably, half for Not sure, and one fifth for Probably not. An honest answer here is what makes the verdicts useful.

What if something has sentimental value?

Mark it as irreplaceable. The calculator won't give those items a keep or let go verdict, because no formula should price a keepsake. It shows what keeping them costs so you can decide with the full picture, and it counts their space when sizing your unit.

What isn't worth putting in storage?

Large things that are inexpensive to replace are the usual culprits: flat-pack furniture, mattresses near the end of their life, older appliances, duplicates, and electronics that lose value quickly. Stored for a long stretch, they can cost more than buying new. Run them through the calculator before you commit.

Should I store or sell my furniture when I move?

If you'll need it back within a few months, storing usually wins, especially once you count the time it takes to sell and rebuy. If the gap is open-ended, sell or donate the large, inexpensive pieces and store the valuable, compact, and irreplaceable ones. The calculator sorts your list for you.

Can I rent a storage unit for just a few months?

Yes. Every 10 Federal rental is month-to-month, so you can store for as long or as short a time as you need. That also makes it easy to rerun your list every few months and let go of things once they stop earning their space.

Store What's Worth Keeping

Month-to-month rentals, 24/7 gate access at nearly every facility, and a friendly customer support team when you need a hand.

Find a unit